Princess persimmon - going for big bucks...

Male-Female what's going on?

The genus Diospyros has about 200 species, the majority are sub-tropical to fully tropical. The genus Diospyros includes all true persimmons and all true ebony species. As a generalization ALL species generally are dioecious, meaning each tree produces imperfect flowers, that are only one gender or the other. So because a tree will only make either male or female flowers you generally need one of each. This is true whether you are talking about the culinary Japanese persimmon - kaki, or talking abou Ceylonese Ebony.

HOWEVER - The segregation is not perfect. There are occasional mistakes. So if you plant 1000 seedlings and flower them out, more than 99% will be either all male, or all female. But occasionally, at the rate of maybe 1 in 1000 will have one of two mistakes in them. Occasionally there is the clone that will have both male and female flowers on the same tree. Often it is mostly female with just a few male flowers. This is the case with Diospyros virginiana 'Meader', a self fruitful American persimmon.

The second mistake is that occasionally a female tree will flower, and if the flower does not get pollinated, the flower will still go ahead and make a fruit. The fruit will then be seedless. In the case of the culinary Japanese persimmon, Diospyros kaki, this is how you get those big persimmon fruit in the market that have no seed. The ability to produce seedless fruit if not pollinated is not a common mutation, but because D. kaki has been cultivated for fruit for at least 4000 years or more, there has been plenty of time to select and propagate only those clones of D, kaki that will make seedless fruit when no pollinator is around. Note, all these females that will produce seedless fruit if no male is around, will make fruit with seed if a male pollinator is present.

So there are 2 different natural mechanisms to get fruit without having a separate male tree. One is have a clone that produces both male and female, and the other is to have a clone that produces seedless fruit when no pollinator is around.
These mechanisms occur in all Diospyros species, but only the cultivated ones have they been selected for and become common.

Diospyros rhombifolia - Princess persimmon, - hardy at most to zone 7, I would protect from temperatures below +10 F or --12 C. They prefer bright shade. I have heard some females that produce seedless fruit have been identified in Japan. Most or all that are currently in USA need both male and female to produce fruit.

Diospyros virginiana - American persimmon - reliably hardy through zone 6, -10 F or - 23 C. Likes more sun than princess persimmon, part shade to full sun. Has rough square block, deeply fissured bark with maturity. Will fruit in as little as 7 years from seed. One clone 'Meader' has been identified as producing mostly female flowers with an occasional male flower, so somewhat self fertile. My information may not be correct but I believe the cultivar 'Yates' has shown it can produce seedless fruit if no male is present. Otherwise the vast majority of named clones and un-named seedlings need a separate male pollinator.

Diospyros kaki - Japanese persimmon, the culinary persimmon for commercial fruit. Because of the 4000 years of being bred and selected for a food crop, many clones, vast majority of clones that are named will produce seedless fruit if no male pollinator is present. So in general, if you purchase a grafted, named D. kaki, it will produce seedless fruit with no male present. Most are only hardy through zone 7. If a male is present, it will make fruit with seed.

Diospyros texana - Texas or Mexican persimmon - small black fruit, shrub similar to Princess persimmon except fruit is black. Native to middle and southern parts of Texas, south into Mexico. Fairly uncommon in cultivation. Definitely worth growing if you find Princess persimmon too expensive to get a hold of.

Diospyros digyna - Chocolate pudding fruit - a tropical persimmon, with fruit that does indeed taste like pudding, and if you use your imagination, chocolate pudding. Not frost tolerant. Separate male and female trees. Leaves are rather large, but do reduce, plan on larger size for bonsai. Not much in the way of selective breeding has been done, so no clones identified. Need male and female to get fruit.

There are a number of South African Diospyros that have bonsai potential, especially the ''crocodile barked persimmon''. I need to look up species names, my memory fails me here. Need separate male and female trees.

Majority of persimmon will fruit at less than 10 years from seed with good horticulture.
 
My understanding is that they need a male to fruit... UNLESS it is a female graft on male rootstock, at which point it becomes self-pollinating.

I have a male and female, so all I can say is my female fruited this year. Would it have fruited without the male? I have no idea.
That makes no sense. A female is not going to fruit because of a male rootstock. The male flower is what it needs. There are a lot of native persimmons on the east coast but I don't know if they will pollinate these Asian varieties. Many female plants can produce male flowers along with female if they are under stress. I don't know if this is true of persimmon.
 
That makes no sense. A female is not going to fruit because of a male rootstock. The male flower is what it needs. There are a lot of native persimmons on the east coast but I don't know if they will pollinate these Asian varieties. Many female plants can produce male flowers along with female if they are under stress. I don't know if this is true of persimmon.

Looking back at this post, I mis-stated what I had read. Instead of male rootstock, replace it with male tree. If you take a female scion and graft it onto a male tree, the resulting plant becomes self-pollinating because there are both male and female branches (and flowers) on the same tree.
 
Looking back at this post, I mis-stated what I had read. Instead of male rootstock, replace it with male tree. If you take a female scion and graft it onto a male tree, the resulting plant becomes self-pollinating because there are both male and female branches (and flowers) on the same tree.
This is very true.
 
Speaking of fruit...I seen one ask the question if the seller had a photo of this tree with fruit on it. Apparently a non-bidder? Because that question was removed.
Yes, that was my question in the auction. I was not going to bid unless I saw a pic with actual fruit on the tree and a male that I could purchase to go with the tree. Nice shohin but I was not going to blindly bid without answers.
 
Yes, that was my question in the auction. I was not going to bid unless I saw a pic with actual fruit on the tree and a male that I could purchase to go with the tree. Nice shohin but I was not going to blindly bid without answers.
Would have liked to see a photo of it with fruit. If it produces fruit I am sure it would have been a good photo to share. The fruit on the pot was shaped differently than Adair's photo. So it makes me question the fruit for the photo shoot. But either or...it is a nice specimen. Female in the listing. Shame no actual photo of it with fruit. I thought your question a good one. Had hoped seller would have shared a photo then...but the question was deleted.
 
The fruit on the pot was shaped differently than Adair's photo. So it makes me question the fruit for the photo shoot.
Many of these are seed grown so the fruit shapes/sizes/coloring can vary quite a bit from specimen to specimen. There is no reason to doubt that the fruit on
the soil came from that tree (why else would he put it there)? It looked like a rounder form compared to the pointy/elongated shape in the photo Adair showed.
I prefer the pointy ones. Some trees produce fruit that has attractive specking on it as well (I guess the attractiveness of that would be personal preference, but
I like it).

It is somewhat odd that he didn't post a photo of it with the fruit, maybe he acquired it recently and the fruit had fallen off. There are several fruit "bracts" still on
the tree so unless he glued them on, it's a female :)

There was another person offering small plants (root cuttings mostly) of "female princess persimmon" on 99cent bonsai auction. I think Judy bought one. I asked
the seller what the fruit was like but he couldn't tell me, so I decided not to purchase. I want to make sure, when (if) I get one, it has a fruit shape that I like as that's
the main feature in my eyes.
 
Many of these are seed grown so the fruit shapes/sizes/coloring can vary quite a bit from specimen to specimen. There is no reason to doubt that the fruit on
the soil came from that tree (why else would he put it there)? It looked like a rounder form compared to the pointy/elongated shape in the photo Adair showed.
I prefer the pointy ones. Some trees produce fruit that has attractive specking on it as well (I guess the attractiveness of that would be personal preference, but
I like it).

It is somewhat odd that he didn't post a photo of it with the fruit, maybe he acquired it recently and the fruit had fallen off. There are several fruit "bracts" still on
the tree so unless he glued them on, it's a female :)

There was another person offering small plants (root cuttings mostly) of "female princess persimmon" on 99cent bonsai auction. I think Judy bought one. I asked
the seller what the fruit was like but he couldn't tell me, so I decided not to purchase. I want to make sure, when (if) I get one, it has a fruit shape that I like as that's
the main feature in my eyes.
Very informative. And cool about the fruits being different shapes, and then the speckled fruit as well is cool.
 
So @Adair M , is this your tree?
Wondering if it's true about self pollination, looking for people who have the species to speak about it...
Judy, it is not my tree. It belongs to John Kirby, who I believe has bud on the tree in question. This is the first time the tree has borne fruit, and there was no BIB show this year! So, John was kind enough to let me borrow it for the Winter Silohette Show. I’m taking it back to Boon’s next week.

The tree had been kept at Boon’s in Hayward, CA until last June when Boon moved to the Central Valley.

Now, Boon has a couple thousand trees in his garden. I’ve been there a lot, and I’m pretty familiar with most of them, but I don’t remember seeing any other persimmons. So, I can’t say anything now, BUT, I will ask Boon when I get there on Monday.

I have to say it was very kind of John to loan to tree to me for the show. It really made a great impression. I put it in one of my pots for the show.

Joe Noga photographed the trees in the show, and I plan to give John a framed photo if the tree as a “Thank you”. (Don’t tell him! Ssshhhh....)
 
The tree had been kept at Boon’s in Hayward, CA until last June when Boon moved to the Central Valley.

Thats the second time I have heard you refer to "CENTRAL VALLEY". Just where did he move? You do understand that anything North of Modesto is not the Central valley anymore.....This state is 1040 miles long. The "Central Valley" is quite small. I live smack dab in the middle of the Central Valley and it runs about 100 miles north and 100 miles south. From the Sierra Nevada's to the East and the Coast Range to the West. About a 100 miles wide.

You may be referencing the San Joaquin Valley which runs much further north and not much more than Bakersfield (about a 100 miles to the south). North of Modesto the San Joaquin Valley receives air from the Bay via the Delta which gives the cooling that us South of Modesto do not get. It is a scorch oven here in the Summer yet the delta will be 80 degrees mid day in August while I am baking at 108.

Trust me, You don't want Boon in the Central Valley, like Kenji Miyata he would be moving again soon. Kenji lost enough that he figured out fast that it wasn't worth his time to grow here. I miss Kenji.
 
Thats the second time I have heard you refer to "CENTRAL VALLEY". Just where did he move? You do understand that anything North of Modesto is not the Central valley anymore.....This state is 1040 miles long. The "Central Valley" is quite small. I live smack dab in the middle of the Central Valley and it runs about 100 miles north and 100 miles south. From the Sierra Nevada's to the East and the Coast Range to the West. About a 100 miles wide.

You may be referencing the San Joaquin Valley which runs much further north and not much more than Bakersfield (about a 100 miles to the south). North of Modesto the San Joaquin Valley receives air from the Bay via the Delta which gives the cooling that us South of Modesto do not get. It is a scorch oven here in the Summer yet the delta will be 80 degrees mid day in August while I am baking at 108.

Trust me, You don't want Boon in the Central Valley, like Kenji Miyata he would be moving again soon. Kenji lost enough that he figured out fast that it wasn't worth his time to grow here. I miss Kenji.
Ok, pardon me if I don’t know my California geography. Boon moved to Valley Springs.
That’s between you and Sacramento. East of Stockton.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Valley_(California)

It appears to me that Valley Springs is pretty much in the middle of “the Central Valley”. Southeast of Sacramento.

I think it’s Calabaras (so?) county where the Gold Rush was. Sutter Creek is not far away.
 
Last edited:
Direct line of Delta air in the foot hills in Gold Country. Thats a long ways from me and not even in the San Joaquin Valley, actually. I asked because California has about ten major climate zones and several hundred micro climates. They are nothing to f*ck around with if you want to grow something much less take care of other peoples trees. We have the tallest mountain on the Continental USA and the lowest spot also. And multitudes of weather in between. Had a tornado in Fresno last night at 3:25 PM, go figure.

I wish him luck there, he is in the middle of fire country and probably got the property cheap. People are moving out of there in record numbers. The numb skulls at the State level know nothing of forest management and a fire can wipe out that part of the state mighty fast. PG&E just filed bankruptcy from all the fires in the state over the last three years. Billions of dollars from faulty and mismanaged power lines.

Only going to be about 30 miles from Scott Chad at Lotus Bonsai. Really great material.
 
I went down to the Bonsai Nursery here in town to take some pictures and get the poop from the owner.

This is a male tree. Fairly large. First the front and then the back.

IMG_5420.jpg

IMG_5419.jpg

This is the female tree with fruit right now. And a close up of the fruit.

IMG_5422.jpg

IMG_5426.jpg

According to him, the female tree will only get fruit if the male is around. The male gets flowers but never gets fruit. The female gets flowers and then bears fruit. If the female is away the male doesn't even get flowers. He has kept them around together for at least 15 years that I know of.

The cool thing I discovered is that the pot of the female tree has many baby plants growing in it. Grey Anderson, owner said he has transplanted them before and they always disappear quickly. I am potting three of them tomorrow. They are just small baby trees but, I can put them into the ground and see what I get before I die. They grow well here.

001.JPG

002.jpg

003.jpg
 
Male-Female what's going on?

The genus Diospyros has about 200 species, the majority are sub-tropical to fully tropical. The genus Diospyros includes all true persimmons and all true ebony species. As a generalization ALL species generally are dioecious, meaning each tree produces imperfect flowers, that are only one gender or the other. So because a tree will only make either male or female flowers you generally need one of each. This is true whether you are talking about the culinary Japanese persimmon - kaki, or talking abou Ceylonese Ebony.

HOWEVER - The segregation is not perfect. There are occasional mistakes. So if you plant 1000 seedlings and flower them out, more than 99% will be either all male, or all female. But occasionally, at the rate of maybe 1 in 1000 will have one of two mistakes in them. Occasionally there is the clone that will have both male and female flowers on the same tree. Often it is mostly female with just a few male flowers. This is the case with Diospyros virginiana 'Meader', a self fruitful American persimmon.

The second mistake is that occasionally a female tree will flower, and if the flower does not get pollinated, the flower will still go ahead and make a fruit. The fruit will then be seedless. In the case of the culinary Japanese persimmon, Diospyros kaki, this is how you get those big persimmon fruit in the market that have no seed. The ability to produce seedless fruit if not pollinated is not a common mutation, but because D. kaki has been cultivated for fruit for at least 4000 years or more, there has been plenty of time to select and propagate only those clones of D, kaki that will make seedless fruit when no pollinator is around. Note, all these females that will produce seedless fruit if no male is around, will make fruit with seed if a male pollinator is present.

So there are 2 different natural mechanisms to get fruit without having a separate male tree. One is have a clone that produces both male and female, and the other is to have a clone that produces seedless fruit when no pollinator is around.
These mechanisms occur in all Diospyros species, but only the cultivated ones have they been selected for and become common.

Diospyros rhombifolia - Princess persimmon, - hardy at most to zone 7, I would protect from temperatures below +10 F or --12 C. They prefer bright shade. I have heard some females that produce seedless fruit have been identified in Japan. Most or all that are currently in USA need both male and female to produce fruit.

Diospyros virginiana - American persimmon - reliably hardy through zone 6, -10 F or - 23 C. Likes more sun than princess persimmon, part shade to full sun. Has rough square block, deeply fissured bark with maturity. Will fruit in as little as 7 years from seed. One clone 'Meader' has been identified as producing mostly female flowers with an occasional male flower, so somewhat self fertile. My information may not be correct but I believe the cultivar 'Yates' has shown it can produce seedless fruit if no male is present. Otherwise the vast majority of named clones and un-named seedlings need a separate male pollinator.

Diospyros kaki - Japanese persimmon, the culinary persimmon for commercial fruit. Because of the 4000 years of being bred and selected for a food crop, many clones, vast majority of clones that are named will produce seedless fruit if no male pollinator is present. So in general, if you purchase a grafted, named D. kaki, it will produce seedless fruit with no male present. Most are only hardy through zone 7. If a male is present, it will make fruit with seed.

Diospyros texana - Texas or Mexican persimmon - small black fruit, shrub similar to Princess persimmon except fruit is black. Native to middle and southern parts of Texas, south into Mexico. Fairly uncommon in cultivation. Definitely worth growing if you find Princess persimmon too expensive to get a hold of.

Diospyros digyna - Chocolate pudding fruit - a tropical persimmon, with fruit that does indeed taste like pudding, and if you use your imagination, chocolate pudding. Not frost tolerant. Separate male and female trees. Leaves are rather large, but do reduce, plan on larger size for bonsai. Not much in the way of selective breeding has been done, so no clones identified. Need male and female to get fruit.

There are a number of South African Diospyros that have bonsai potential, especially the ''crocodile barked persimmon''. I need to look up species names, my memory fails me here. Need separate male and female trees.

Majority of persimmon will fruit at less than 10 years from seed with good horticulture.

Thank you. Great info:).
 
Indeed seems like a hot plant right now. They are quite beautiful in winter with their tiny orange fruit against the light grey bark. There are varieties within D. rhombifolia that have fruit that looks like cherry tomatoes in color and shape. There are others like mine that have slightly larger and more elongated fruit which I prefer but does not seem to be as prolific. I also have a male tree that flowers heavily in spring.

In my experience they take well to wiring although they look best when designed in what I call "free form" style. Below is a photo of when it was displayed at the Winter Silhouette Expo in Kannapolis in 2017 and a summer pic in full leaf where you can see the fruit forming.



 
Last edited:
So @Adair M , is this your tree?
Wondering if it's true about self pollination, looking for people who have the species to speak about it...

Judy,

I don't have one, but some of the guys in my club do. They get fruit and have no males, but in our area we have a lot of wild persimmon around here and I am told that it serves as the pollinators.
 
Here is an old bssf article regarding persimmons and dennis vojtilla. He moved to oregon a number of years ago and a bunch of his persimmons. he has a vineyard somewhere outside of portland. http://www.bssf.org/articles-and-stories/january-meeting-notes/

I have spoken to Dennis in the past about Princess Persimmon... and air-layering. Different people have different experiences. Some say it can be done, some say it can be done but it's hard, some haven't been able to do it. Dennis' opinion was that air-layering was difficult and the results for him were poor. He believes the best way to propagate is through root cuttings, and said that the trees have a tendency to generate large thick roots that work well for this purpose.
 
Back
Top Bottom