Black Pine Seedling Cuttings

A few updates. Here is the semi-cascade exposed root. I cut off the main sacrifice trunk and edited several unneeded branches. I then thinned and pulled needles And tightened the bend a bit more. Main branches and trunk line are in place. Before and after.01DF7A1B-64C1-47D4-B3F1-52425D463481.jpeg816F7D6C-4F1A-433F-808C-209568B8D4E7.jpeg
 
I removed the wrap and twine holding the roots to the rock in this root-over-rock tree. Here are a few shots during the process from different sides of the tree. The roots turned out great on this one - I’m going to call the packing wrap experiment a success! I kept the escape branch, but removed the needles and cut off everything except for the leader. Around the rest of the tree I just pulled some needles. Plan is to develop a new trunk line and the branches from the whorl just a few inches above the top of the rock.42B8ED15-F1DC-49E4-AA68-A1B199F55346.jpeg5FFA73DD-2709-4876-AFC8-176E9008C2D5.jpegADFDF537-CA04-44ED-90CD-948A09007323.jpeg82299D93-0917-458C-BAFF-2F539B112EE5.jpeg3011695D-297B-442C-972D-456319B2B152.jpegF419BC6B-A3DE-4070-BB45-CBF34DB6B0F3.jpeg8EBD31CF-1CEC-40A8-9617-36CAAFD27470.jpeg.
 
One of my exposed root trees just wasn’t working out. So it became a root over rock. Heres some nice limestone for rock plantings. C1BEA327-BC24-49FC-9A1B-2ED21A19E8CC.jpegB16384D2-4AE0-40B1-87A0-AC53AB7BB967.jpeg
 
Here’s the tree attached to a stone. I bare rooted the tree and, with some pretty sketchy engineering, attached it to the stone and secured the roots around it with packing film and aluminum wire DCA7D136-D091-4E39-AD3F-3C039AB8C33A.jpeg8F3C23C8-A90B-453F-9A41-6FACB8F66453.jpeg1224C61C-F4F2-4C18-9EBF-327F474187B3.jpeg0A75FA19-0A78-4994-9243-E7699DE143FE.jpeg
 
Wouldn't root over a smooth (instead of rough/clingy) rock be a way to produce exposed roots? That is, one would do everything in the same way, but removes the rock in the end (because it isn't 'welded' to the rock).

BTW, I've noticed that there are lots of trees that were growing on stumps (of trees that were logged 60+ years ago) are now becoming exposed root trees as the old stumps are now rapidly decaying. I imagine, though, that most naturally occurring exposed roots are the result of progressive soil erosion.

Apologies for bombing your thread - just had an overwhelming need to share 🙄
 
Last edited:
Wouldn't root over a smooth (instead of rough/clingy) rock be a way to produce exposed roots? That is, one would do everything in the same way, but removes the rock in the end (because it isn't 'welded' to the rock).
Artistic preference, but I personally prefer textured stones with hollows, grooves and irregular edges over a smooth stone. It needs to be a good interesting one - trees change but stones don’t.
 
BTW, I've noticed that there are lots of trees that were growing on stumps (of trees that were logged 60+ years ago) are now becoming exposed root trees as the old stumps are now rapidly decaying. I imagine, though, that most naturally occurring exposed roots are the result of progressive soil erosion.
It seems likely that exposed root trees were originally motivated by both of those processes. Over time, they developed a unique asthetic of their own.
S
 
Here’s a progression on the cascade from the beginning:

March 2015
543889A9-521E-49CF-B48C-15A52617EE6E.jpeg

August 2016
FD1878E3-BA93-45EB-B631-380D90D814C4.jpeg

November 2016
64123050-2672-4341-97F2-60AFF84104BC.jpeg

December 2016
37A5BD65-5C79-4CB2-8D4E-E41106282417.jpeg

February 2017
359597F5-D5C9-4091-9E7F-CDC7BDEFB0BF.jpeg

October 2017
AD6E4F3B-AA8D-4B33-8B86-0BA9355B5C9C.jpeg

April 2018
3979C020-78E8-4CA8-B072-8651CA7F1FE5.jpeg

January 2019
12D31A92-CFC9-472A-90BC-26D260B20AE2.jpeg

January 2019
6FB5291B-A392-4C78-AB8C-C53545DCFC20.jpeg

July 2020
087B8A28-97B2-40CB-81AF-10B780B14E1D.jpeg

February 2021
7BE97C93-3DA0-4C84-B3AC-B7B672C38B88.jpeg

April 2021
0B68C925-A1D1-4B30-9A6A-27CB0D88DF48.jpeg

July 2021
3246CCA8-83FC-4E9E-87D2-9E45C617E6BD.jpeg

January 2023
E4F8CD1F-DAD9-4FBC-96D2-316D3D0BFE7B.jpeg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Here’s a progression on the cascade from the beginning:

March 2015
View attachment 468463

August 2016
View attachment 468470

November 2016
View attachment 468464

December 2016
View attachment 468465

February 2017
View attachment 468466

October 2017
View attachment 468467

April 2018
View attachment 468469

January 2019
View attachment 468480

January 2019
View attachment 468472

July 2020
View attachment 468473

February 2021
View attachment 468475

April 2021
View attachment 468476

July 2021
View attachment 468477

January 2022
View attachment 468487
Great progression and lesson on what can be done with experience.
 
Crap. Yes.

And the time to edit has expired, so now preserved forever. Thanks for catching that!

s
I *think* if you ask @Bonsai Nut nicely, there are ways to correct such confusing mistakes. Some of the feebler minded, such as myself, might in a year be utterly confused with your timelines!
 
I *think* if you ask @Bonsai Nut nicely, there are ways to correct such confusing mistakes. Some of the feebler minded, such as myself, might in a year be utterly confused with your timelines!
What do you think @Bonsai Nut? The public has spoken. Any chance we can edit post 472? The label for the last image should be 2023, not 2022. thank you!

S
 
What do you think @Bonsai Nut? The public has spoken. Any chance we can edit post 472? The label for the last image should be 2023, not 2022. thank you!

S
LOL I changed it hours ago. I should have said something :)
 
Back
Top Bottom