I recently bought a 7 gallon Japanese Black Pine Witches Broom. Over 3/4s of the many branches will need to be removed to cut it back to a hard line. I just started applying airlayers on the larger branches using Dip-N-Grow undiluted and damp spagnum moss with SuperThrive added, starting at the top and working downwards to get more sunlight to the inside branches. I estimate that over 50+ branches will have to be removed. This might make good use of the Airlayers if they are successful. This has JBP rootstock with a JBP scion grafted to it about 8" above the soil level, it has bad reverse taper at the graft that will need to be carved out over several years. In 2020 I put cleft grafts on JBP rootstock with Pinus Clausa Witches Broom scions, I had two that made it, it has 1.25" needles without any reduction! I just bought two dozen JBP seedlings in 3" bulb pans that are waking up this week, I'm gonna try your technique with the new seedlings and leftover 3 year seedlings, I have everything except for the BBQ lava rocks. I'm located in zone 10b that is towards the south end of JBPs range. I'm gonna try using both large size BBQ lava and use 1/4" red lava as I have over (30 ) 20 lb bags of 1/4" lava as a control.
Thanks for passing your knowledge to All !
Millard