I love this insight, Shady! Funny you suggest embracing the weeping nature. @Hartinez also made a similar suggestion awhile back! I think it’s really an interesting idea.
A couple weeks ago our club had a live Zoom Q&A with Ryan Neil. Ask him whatever you want about bonsai. I asked a question about “weeping style” RMJs. He basically poo-poo’d the idea. This has me really torn because I really admire his work and follow his teachings/techniques quite religiously, however I feel like perhaps he was being a little bit closed minded. Conversely, perhaps I am just being ignorant
Anyway, “so emo it practically prunes itself.” Can we make t-shirts with this quote? I’m imagining a “Brand New” album as this tree’s accent piece
Interesting, thanks for sharing! Glad to know I’m not the only one that finds it challenging at times. I will say that I do have/have had a few other RMJs that had better foliage. Definitely some are better than others.Was at Eisei-en last week and Bjorn said he might no longer accept RMJ work because of this exact reason. The foliage is exceptionally tedious to work with; droopy and doesn’t like to hold its shape. I have one of his RMJs that he tried to graft itoigawa on (but all 30+ grafts failed) and he outright advised me to keep the foliage juvenile unless I like suffering
Some definitely have better foliage! I have a couple of each native junipers and it’s pretty amazing to see how varied their foliage can be despite being the same species.Interesting, thanks for sharing! Glad to know I’m not the only one that finds it challenging at times. I will say that I do have/have had a few other RMJs that had better foliage. Definitely some are better than others.
Looks like you have some great trees, by the way!
Some definitely have better foliage! I have a couple of each native junipers and it’s pretty amazing to see how varied their foliage can be despite being the same species.
Thanks! Definitely added a few too many trees this year but it just meant I had to learn things quicker too. Been enjoying the updates to your garden! I’ve been making some to mine as well as the collection grew so getting ideas/inspiration from your thread. Absolutely love those benches with the smaller stone. I’ve been unable to locate them locally. Or at least not at a reasonable cost(Home depot has a similar sized one that was $900 but would only build 1.5 benches at the height I want lol). Do you have a local source with better pricing?
Japanese White Birch
Thank you! It has been in this pot for 3 seasons now, planning to repot in the spring. Thinking something a little shallower and wider.I like that image a lot. Many birch I see by mountain streams grow like this. Well done.
Thanks for the kind words! For the aspen, I’m planning to pot it into a shallow oval in the spring. Once I find the best combination of base and line for the front, I think I’ll need to reposition some branches with wire.These pictures really don't do your trees justice TJ, but they still look fantastic. The sillhoute on that Aspen is so delicate, I love it. What are you planning for it down the line?
I'm leaning toward the literati idea right now.Here’s a humble Chinese elm mallsai. It has the dreaded S-curve but I’m having fun trying to make a literati out of it. Could always chop it back to the base, but for now I’m having fun with it!
View attachment 464542
View attachment 464541
Thoughts? Keep experimenting with literati form, or chop it back to the first branch?
Here’s a humble Chinese elm mallsai. It has the dreaded S-curve but I’m having fun trying to make a literati out of it [...] Thoughts? Keep experimenting with literati form, or chop it back to the first branch?
I’d leave it like this and experiment with it.Here’s a humble Chinese elm mallsai. It has the dreaded S-curve but I’m having fun trying to make a literati out of it. Could always chop it back to the base, but for now I’m having fun with it!
View attachment 464542
View attachment 464541
Thoughts? Keep experimenting with literati form, or chop it back to the first branch?
Best of both worlds? Layer at the orange line to keep the literati and get rid of the s-curve. Then chop back to the blue line and build off the base. I really like the literati part you've built, but the s-curve feels very different for some reason
View attachment 464567
I’d leave it like this and experiment with it.
Even though it has the S at the base still looks good.
The best thing to do in bonsai, somethimes, is to do nothing (some old bonsai master once said)
This tree is actually inspirational for me, I have a similar S malsai supermarket bought elm.Thanks! And totally agree about doing nothing sometimes. Can always come back later and “do” the thing if it still seems like a good idea.
Awesome!This tree is actually inspirational for me, I have a similar S malsai supermarket bought elm.
Was thinking what to do with it.
Will take it next spring in a similar direction.