bonhe
Masterpiece
Thanks. I check info in this site https://conifersociety.org/conifers/pinus-hwangshanensisI
was listing, huangshan, Japanese red pine, and Japanese black pine. Sorry for the confusion.
It is similar to Black pine and P. nigra. It is why the seller to whom I bought the seeds from just ads as Huangshan pine .
I am guessing it might be hybrid between black pine and red pine based on the color of the buds.
They already show some interesting characters at this phase .
I found two of them have long, flexible trunks
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/66e5d/66e5d9be2cdb4f613e765e611c8fddc43f47453d" alt="0EE0DEA6-2F34-469D-B427-A3E6879F7A0C.jpeg 0EE0DEA6-2F34-469D-B427-A3E6879F7A0C.jpeg"
The one on the right has primary needles with short trunk
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e4263/e4263beaf8a9c983b433719b7295ebb270ada88b" alt="71010E6B-0B27-4A23-8637-0C724CCAFBEB.jpeg 71010E6B-0B27-4A23-8637-0C724CCAFBEB.jpeg"
The 1st one in the group
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8e0d5/8e0d591699fa2d4506647cddd765cad53274c618" alt="BCDBFD40-E8E2-4B99-9914-7A8E9745938C.jpeg BCDBFD40-E8E2-4B99-9914-7A8E9745938C.jpeg"
I don’t remember I put 2 seeds into the same hole, but there are 2 now!!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/69e7c/69e7c0822398dee1eb2c0ad47cbe85dae8a243f4" alt="EEC6684B-5FAD-4658-B7B2-46403A1C949E.jpeg EEC6684B-5FAD-4658-B7B2-46403A1C949E.jpeg"
Thụ Thoại