Spruce/Picea Abies

Hi Tycoss, youre right it needs to be reduced or further taper added, i think i could even go as far as taking the dead stump down by half, as the tree is now heading towards something similar to the one in the G potter vid i posted on the other page...
ive been looking at some options, no rush though, i want the wood to dry out a little
spruce-bonsai-1393780.jpg
 
You're certainly not shy about going straight for the image you're after are you? I probably would have taken about four years of gradual reduction and strengthening of the keeper branch to get to that point!
Looking forward to seeing how it responds for you.
There's more than enough root in the pot to power that little branch, there's been no flow disrupted on that side whatsoever and thats the strongest part of the tree according to the root formation and veins directly under that branch. but i know spruce can be finicky about having this much foliage removed in one go, its more an experiment i guess...where i got this tree there must be a 100 others, some with bigger trunks, some smaller. if this one doesnt respond in spring, i'd be tempted to get another and work it differently.
the material ive been working on lately are all very well established trees, with roots bursting out of the pot, time will tell if i get away with it, the yews ive worked on lately have had the same treatment, there are also plenty more where i got those.
rather than over working my other trees, ive been picking up these new raw bits for dirt cheap and practising on them, it keeps me busy, but i think they all have potential if i can keep them alive, ive also learnt a a lot and improved certain skills.

Ive picked up loads of bits over the past few weeks, i dont post everything though...
i picked up this beech for £3 it has potential but very early stages
2016-10-25_09-12-11 by Bobby Lane, on Flickr

IMG_2728 by Bobby Lane, on Flickr

a hornbeam with a powerful base, pretty straight trunk, has potential as a basic broom i think, also early days, this was also very cheap
2016-10-19_06-12-06 by Bobby Lane, on Flickr

14657529_1146272242104482_5714137448223192430_n (1) by Bobby Lane, on Flickr
14657529_1146272242104482_5714137448223192430_n by Bobby Lane, on Flickr

so yeah just been having lots of fun tbh:)
 
Last edited:
Its worth considering guys
IMG_3027 by Bobby Lane, on Flickr

will see how it recovers..

Much too much artificial dead wood in my opinion. It doesn't look natural at all with most of the branches on the same side, very 2-D.

The remaining needles look very weak too...

Sorry mate but I think it will take years, if not decades if you want to make it someting decent :(
 
Deadwood is progressive, it doesnt always look right instantly....i agree some of the needles are weak, i dont agree that having branches on one side looks un natural because in nature its quite possible, dont judge my trees with bonsai rules.
jsw_19.jpg

jsw_22.jpg


i dont agree that it would take decades to achieve a decent and healthy looking image. should the tree bounce back in spring and begin growing, i believe i could have a full and compacted canopy in three years.
in the mean time ive been stripping the dead wood, taper has increased. happy to just leave it out to weather now.
2016-11-21_09-58-02 by Bobby Lane, on Flickr
 
Not able to edit my post, just wanted to add that an apex growing up the side of a tree is not uncommon in nature, especially in Spruce, this can often happen to trees high up in the mountains where they've had some sort of trauma be it a lightening strike or a rock fall or boulder damaging the main trunk. arranging the branches of that apex for depth would be the next step, ive done that here.
 
I like how you went all the way with it... Might as well get it done now...
I have taken that approach before with good and bad results...
No risk, no reward.
Cool work!
....and I see trees like that all the time, in nature.
It might look kinda weird now, because of the thickness of the jinned trunk, but the new one will fatten up and look great eventually.
 
Im still seeing one or two options here...Yep, you can sit and wait for the new apex to fatten up and build a nice image in the end, or you can let the tree get healthy, compact and reduce the canopy all together and have another type of image
this is another WP tree
2015-05-SAL_1410w.jpg

1.jpg




The tree below is an exibition tree, noelanders i think, the apex is no where as thick as the trunk, but the carving/deadwood makes it all marry together....another possible option imo
kai8.jpg
 
Last edited:
There are those who will look at the images ive posted, with contempt and disgust...but each to their own i guess. but one thing you can't do is disregard nature and what is a part of our landscape. i could post hundreds of examples
 
As I said in the previous post, growth in the apex will help solve the issue with proportion. Remember too that the deadwood will age while the crown is developing. In about 5 years when the crown looks decent, the deadwood will also look much more natural.
 
Back
Top Bottom