Results of Joshua New Talent Contest !

Toss up between #2 and #5 for me, at least based on the single photos. These give the most immediate impression of "bonsai". Some of the others may have good or even better long term potential but I'm guessing the intent of the competition is to produce something that looks like "bonsai" right now? Could be wrong about that.

Chris
 
BTW, the winner is even more deserving if you see the stock he started with. I honestly didn't see the bonsai in there (that he did) initially.

This...
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • stock.jpg
    stock.jpg
    119 KB · Views: 210
Last edited:
Looks like #5 to me...
 
For me, the best tree is 3. I saw the others and how they were worked. I knew when I left which tree would be best just by the way it was wired. That shows.
 
#3 does look like it's wired very well and meticulously styled. I don't like the overall appearance right now (canopy shape and that one trunk segment on the left) as much as the other two, but it might turn out better in the long run. If I saw them all in person my opinion might change since photos make some trees look better and some look worse.
 
#3 does look like it's wired very well and meticulously styled. I don't like the overall appearance right now (canopy shape and that one trunk segment on the left) as much as the other two, but it might turn out better in the long run. If I saw them all in person my opinion might change since photos make some trees look better and some look worse.

I agree. IMHO the bottom left pad took something from the tree than add. The "arched branch/trunk" made it feel weird to me visually.
 
For me, the best tree is 3. I saw the others and how they were worked. I knew when I left which tree would be best just by the way it was wired. That shows.

See...seeing them in person also has a better overall feeling. My two were for 5&3... But the base on 4 was impressive.
 
I would have liked to see a better angle of #2. The photo I don't feel shows off the carving well...the base seemed interesting...but not in detail enough to appreciate it.
 
You did... and they were only $75 dollars if you wanted to...
Which was a steal !

I didn't though, for unless I shipped it, I could of not got it
Home.

So, mine was auctioned off. Curious to know how much it went
For? Last years went for $350 dollars.

Stacy, I was the auctioneer but honestly don't remember exactly what your tree went for. I think around $400. Great work, by the way.
I think each of the top four trees had at least one aspect that could have made it a winner. You (#3), as you said, had one of the more challenging ones to begin with and did by far the best detail wiring and shaping and achieved the most "finished looking" tree. Vic (#2) did some amazing carving work but I think spent so much time on the carving that she could have done better with wiring and branch placement. Ron's tree (#4) was in my opinion the best raw material to start with. I think, like most new artists, he left too much that should have been removed to make a better tree. Ryan, (#5), the winner, demonstrated the best technique for moving and placing the large branches. I can see the influence of another Ryan I know in his work. He clearly was more concerned with creating a great branch structure for the future at the cost of an immediate refined look like yours.
These were really nice old trees that were chosen to present challenges that would allow you guys to demonstrate your stuff. And you all came through. I was able to cruise out to the tent several times through the day and watch. The change from the raw material in the morning to the trees that evening was most impressive!
FYI, these were San Jose junipers that Scott Chadd found at a nursery in Gilroy, CA, and had been in those 5 gallon pots for 35 years! Next challenge... root work.

I'm glad I wasn't the judge! Congratulations on fine work.
 
I liked 3 the most overall, nice job.

Victrina's carving is very nice looking too, just needed some fine wiring to make it look more polished.
And number 5 is very nice as well and would have got 2nd in my opinion. Some of the branches don't look exactly in the right spot in my opinion. Something about that bottom branch on that one i find distracting. I don't know exactly what it is but i feel like it should go down more instead of coming back up.

Thanks for sharing.
 
Peoples Choice

Does anyone know what tree received the peoples choice?
 
Back
Top Bottom