Thanks again for all the insights and advice! This kept me awake in bed and smiling all night!
I was hoping I could please ask about a few more specifics?
1 - Was it just girth itself that caught your attention, or also age? i.e. When you took the cuttings in November, did you only use growth that pushed from March to November of the same year, or did you also cut into growth from previous years? If so, did you track it and notice a difference?
2 - I noticed a little fertilizer (?) on the surface around the cuttings in your picture in post #18. Can I please ask what it is/when it was applied etc.?
3 - I've been chatting with Brent about Ume cuttings for over 2 years now. He mentioned recently the idea of using fungicides (or at least Root Tone, which includes a fungicide). Was wondering if you used any fungicides or rooting hormones? My teacher uses Stim-Root #3 on his successful Ume cuttings taken in May.
Bottom temp 18C (65F)?
1.Juvenility is a critical factor in success, current years growth only!
2. I make my own organic fertilizer, suggest one that is low numbers, all three below 10. Lots of options out there! I applied when the leaves were just opening. Remember in this situation, inorganic soil medium primarily, it takes a while for the organic fertilizer to break down to available elements for uptake! Another safe option is dilute liquid fish fertilizer! ( not my preference if indoors).
3. I used hydrogen peroxide in water to mist cuttings weekly and also for initial drench watering source.( credit this idea from Osoyoung) Pre-treated the small particle pumice with same solution and then dried thoroughly before use! My pumice comes bagged and is often damp inside the bag so after sifting to size the pumice used for cuttings and seedlings is treated! ( how effective this treatment is I have no idea! ). I wash the pumice thoroughly to remove fines prior to treatment! Used a grey powder ( StimRoot #3) meant for hardwood cuttings. available in most garden centres.
4. My setting was a bit higher 72F,
The approach I used to research this was to start with known approaches, basically the notes from Peter Adams and from discussion with Brent. I then went to The Reference Manual of Woody Plant Propagation and studied the approach to Prunus cuttings, particularly those known to be difficult, looking for commonalities in successful approaches! Note: Prunus Mume is not in the book
. I then went back to study the factors that affect root formation and the factors that affect cutting success in general. I also noted the factors that increase fungal issues. ( a big problem with prunus mume)
After that trial and error! Lots of room for improvement, it is a good thing younger generations exist, inquiring minds and all that!
Remember I am not a horticulturist, simply working on a puzzle with tools available!