Hypertufa, won't be freeze - thaw resistant, and part of it's "charm" is the degradation. Usually by 5th spring, after freezing and thawing it will crumble to a pile of grit. The peat moss, or paper in the mix will wick water into the walls of the pot. The peat also supports the colonization by moss, another feature of hypertufa. Walls of hypertufa pots need to be thicker than those of shape-crete in order to last more than one or two winters. In mild climates hypertufa is much longer lasting. Seriously the decay process of hypertufa is one of it's artistic charms, and why it is used.
I think shape-crete is a good product, similar or superior to the Ciment Fondue that Eric K of the I think Czech Republic uses to make those wild free form pots he is famous for.