Same here. I still update my progression threads, because I want an easy way to track what I'm doing.I don't think this threat stops people from doing the progression threads for their individual trees.
Squirrels building nestsSpent last last few days trying to figure out why I keep finding cut branches of my S Maple shade tree. Clean 45* degree cuts from high in the tree. Whacha think it is?
View attachment 602872
View attachment 602873
View attachment 602874
Squirrels? I have tons of them. More of a why/how come every morning half dozen or more will be there.
There is a place for both. Sometimes I make a quick post in this thread just to refer to it later in the progression thread for the tree.I totally understand where @Shogun610 is coming from. The progression threads, done right, are the real jewels of this site. I lurked here for a long time before I ever posted, simply admiring and learning from the decades of work some of the more experienced members have documented. But on the flip side, I think a lot of progression threads are posted a bit prematurely. It is hard to have a ton of discussion on trees just starting their journey. Whether that be a seedling, a stump, a stick in a pot, or a recent air layer. I would encourage people to have a bit of time documented with a tree before they start a progression thread. That way there is more to talk about
I do think there is a place for both. It can be intimidating to put your trees up to the scrutiny of the internet. I know I am victim to this. It is far less intimidating to post my work here then in a thread dedicated to it. That being said, I will make an honest effort to post some progressions.
For photo tax, here is a Dawn Redwood I am working on between meetings this week:
View attachment 602896
I love the progression threads as well, especially when an experienced member has them. I can see what you mean about some threads suffering, but I don't fully agree that this thread is harming the site. (I know you didn't say that) It's all perspective to me, & I'm just looking for any info I can find. I normally click on "newest posts" when I arrive at this site, and I see new content all the time. Another reason I don't have a lot of progression threads is my experience level. 3rd Level Noob Dork only gets me so far.I love the long term progression threads, they give more perspective, and show goals being met than random photos. As much as I love this thread, I feel like everyone stopped progression threads other than a handful of folks, and all i see is those random I did this today photos. So I guess I agree with @Shogun610
Speaking of random photos, here's my photo tax. I unwired some of this year's elms and hornbeams that I wired 2-3 weeks ago before they hardened off. Holding form well. (Bottom couple branches are sacrificial so I didnt wire them) they are all starting to push a third round of ramification already, gotta love a long spring.