Advice to add trunk movement to this Juniper

I would consider airlayering the smaller trunk and turning it into a short jin and shari below. It would create more taper too.


Maybe like this? Airlayer at red, green would be a possible rough silhouette?
View attachment 87487

Or do same thing with the first pic.
The problem I have with this design direction is that you are trying to build a Maple type tree on a Juniper trunk. Junipers are a peculiar beast. They are best served up with a lot of Jins and Shari. You need to look through the books and magazines that picture these trees as bonsai and you will soon realize that most Juniper Bonsai have a lot of dead wood displayed on them. Granted that a great percentage of these trees are collected from the mountains and the dead wood is natural. That does not mean that you cannot make a reasonable bonsai out of a tree like this one creating your own dead wood. But I think I can say; you will not find a World Class Juniper Bonsai without a lot of dead wood.
I would consider airlayering the smaller trunk and turning it into a short jin and shari below. It would create more taper too.


Maybe like this? Airlayer at red, green would be a possible rough silhouette?
View attachment 87487

Or do same thing with the first pic.
I think you need to dedicate a good deal of time researching Juniper Bonsai. I know many of the really good ones are collected trees but there is one thing you will notice rapidly; you will not find a World Class Juiper Bonsai that does not have a display of dead wood. Designing this tree as suggested in the virtual makes your Juniper look more like a Maple, than a Juniper. I know you will probably say that you cannot have dead wood on such a young tree. This is not true and you need to start looking at things in that direction. I think the most important advise you can get with this tree is to leave it alone until you can see a direction. I attached a photo of a Shimpaku of mine that has a lot of deadwood. This is all man made, or man induced is more accurate, but this is the way they grow and you have to go there if you want to good Juniper bonsai. Shimp13.jpg
 
The problem I have with this design direction is that you are trying to build a Maple type tree on a Juniper trunk. Junipers are a peculiar beast. They are best served up with a lot of Jins and Shari. You need to look through the books and magazines that picture these trees as bonsai and you will soon realize that most Juniper Bonsai have a lot of dead wood displayed on them. Granted that a great percentage of these trees are collected from the mountains and the dead wood is natural. That does not mean that you cannot make a reasonable bonsai out of a tree like this one creating your own dead wood. But I think I can say; you will not find a World Class Juniper Bonsai without a lot of dead wood.

I think you need to dedicate a good deal of time researching Juniper Bonsai. I know many of the really good ones are collected trees but there is one thing you will notice rapidly; you will not find a World Class Juiper Bonsai that does not have a display of dead wood. Designing this tree as suggested in the virtual makes your Juniper look more like a Maple, than a Juniper. I know you will probably say that you cannot have dead wood on such a young tree. This is not true and you need to start looking at things in that direction. I think the most important advise you can get with this tree is to leave it alone until you can see a direction. I attached a photo of a Shimpaku of mine that has a lot of deadwood. This is all man made, or man induced is more accurate, but this is the way they grow and you have to go there if you want to good Juniper bonsai. View attachment 87966
You make a good point and I agree that it is a little too maple-ish.

But I don't know if you have noticed that there are no branches to turn into jins and deadwood until you are at least 2/3 the way up the tree. The best solution is to jin the second trunk and then continue a shari from the roots to the jin as I suggested. Or add grafts just to kill and turn into jins?

The last picture definently isn't the best front.

And to be frank, this will never be a world class tree.
 
I am not trying to be pedantic or condescending about the tree. The tree I showed you above took me a lot of years to get to this point. Not because the tree was not ready; I was not read. I was not seeing where this tree could go. You are of course correct you don't have a lot to work on but working out sharis on the trunk is not impossible. Jining the other trunk will give you some interesting things to work with. Junipers in my opinion seem to be an exercise in eliminating stuff instead of growing out stuff unless you are grafting foliage.
 
Thank you both for the lively discussion about my tree. I will be taking the tree to workshops this year and hope to get some great advice about this tree and several other. I have considered the Jin of one of the trunks, as shown in Brian's juniper. Once I feel confident about a particular base and trunk movement, I would then consider the Jin. Thank you everyone.
 
The problem I have with this design direction is that you are trying to build a Maple type tree on a Juniper trunk. Junipers are a peculiar beast. They are best served up with a lot of Jins and Shari. You need to look through the books and magazines that picture these trees as bonsai and you will soon realize that most Juniper Bonsai have a lot of dead wood displayed on them. Granted that a great percentage of these trees are collected from the mountains and the dead wood is natural. That does not mean that you cannot make a reasonable bonsai out of a tree like this one creating your own dead wood. But I think I can say; you will not find a World Class Juniper Bonsai without a lot of dead wood.

I think you need to dedicate a good deal of time researching Juniper Bonsai. I know many of the really good ones are collected trees but there is one thing you will notice rapidly; you will not find a World Class Juiper Bonsai that does not have a display of dead wood. Designing this tree as suggested in the virtual makes your Juniper look more like a Maple, than a Juniper. I know you will probably say that you cannot have dead wood on such a young tree. This is not true and you need to start looking at things in that direction. I think the most important advise you can get with this tree is to leave it alone until you can see a direction. I attached a photo of a Shimpaku of mine that has a lot of deadwood. This is all man made, or man induced is more accurate, but this is the way they grow and you have to go there if you want to good Juniper bonsai. View attachment 87966
Wonderful Juniper! Shimpaku? I'm still learning to view spices by foliage.
 
Shimpaku from a three gallon Nursery tree. Like I mentioned it took me years to get this tree and myself to this point. Following is a history of this tree's development from 2003 to the present.Shimpaku 2003.jpgShimp2005.jpgShimpaku08 copy.jpg Shimp4sesns.jpgShimp13.jpg
 
Shimpaku from a three gallon Nursery tree. Like I mentioned it took me years to get this tree and myself to this point. Following is a history of this tree's development from 2003 to the present.View attachment 87983View attachment 87984View attachment 87985 View attachment 87986View attachment 87987
Great progression. Thank you for sharing the photo history. Wonderful to see a tree grow into its potential.
 
Back
Top Bottom