Yamadori

Damn!

Might as well start stealing stop signs!

Sorce
 
273738

Even if you did not kill it outright, it will take WAY longer to develop than if you had waited. Healthy trees respond so much better that waiting a year for it to get healthy woul dhave safed you in the long run. People are NOT recommending waiting to make you sit around.

If you want to grow bonsai, learning patience is crucial.
People do not kill bonsai, impatience kills bonsai.
 
Its another Triffid tree
tumblr_oz0blabwDG1uyth69o4_400.jpg
 
20191209_161805.jpg

I like what I like and it isn't my first tree. Here is another I trimmed the same way last year now look. Oh my how nice and full. Come on guys what's good for you isn't the same for me. You guys are funny. I'm sorry how upsetting my style is for you. I hope you are all familiar with Peter Chan from Herrons Bonsai. Look him up. Quoting his way. " beauty is in the eye of the beholder and you dont have to always follow traditionalism"
 
Well the other one needs a hope rock too then so it looks like it came from Home Depot. My point and most of the others was to let the thing alone and recover from being dug up a couple months ago. Not hack on it and wire it up while waiting. All that activity stresses the tree more and you probably loosened up some just recovering roots too.
 
Carpenterb30 said:
View attachment 273804

I like what I like and it isn't my first tree. Here is another I trimmed the same way last year now look. Oh my how nice and full. Come on guys what's good for you isn't the same for me. You guys are funny. I'm sorry how upsetting my style is for you. I hope you are all familiar with Peter Chan from Herrons Bonsai. Look him up. Quoting his way. " beauty is in the eye of the beholder and you dont have to always follow traditionalism"
Click to expand...
Your first tree was cool; it has a lot of potential. This one is a mass produced stick in a pot.

More than what you did, it is when you did it. By "styling" your collected tree a few months after collection, and by removing such large amount of foliage, you showed that you don't understand the first thing about junipers.

By showing us this tree, with the little rock and all, you prove to us that you have no taste.

And by quoting Peter Chan, you further prove the above points.
 
bonsaichile said:
Your first tree was cool; it has a lot of potential. This one is a mass produced stick in a pot.

More than what you did, it is when you did it. By "styling" your collected tree a few months after collection, and by removing such large amount of foliage, you showed that you don't understand the first thing about junipers.

By showing us this tree, with the little rock and all, you prove to us that you have no taste.

And by quoting Peter Chan, you further prove the above points.
Click to expand...
thank you, to me it looks like a box store prefab bonsai than something produced at home too. Glued in rocks and all.
 
bonsaichile said:
Your first tree was cool; it has a lot of potential. This one is a mass produced stick in a pot.

More than what you did, it is when you did it. By "styling" your collected tree a few months after collection, and by removing such large amount of foliage, you showed that you don't understand the first thing about junipers.

By showing us this tree, with the little rock and all, you prove to us that you have no taste.

And by quoting Peter Chan, you further prove the above points.
Click to expand...
No not mass produced at all actually about 4 years old grown from a cutting from another tree I have.
 
It is true that beauty is subjective, however beauty is most often viewed as an effect of health and vitality. Its why Jennifer Aniston or Beyonce are generally regarded as "Beautiful" and why the women featured on morbidly obese tv documentaries are not.

I am curious to see your other trees and how they are styled.
 
What I just don't understand is why people post up pics of trees and then ask for thoughts.....get some good advice.....and do the complete opposite?

@Carpenterb30 if you were already planning to prune, why ask for everyone's thoughts? The advice you got was pretty legit. You was advised to hold out before doing anything, then you post pics of what you did.

It just doesn't make sense to me...….
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

G
Post Oak (Quercus stellata) Yamadori - Middle Tennessee
Replies
6
Views
484
Maiden69
Maiden69
M
Urban Yamadori weeping taxus
Replies
0
Views
95
Meeyageesun
M
I_I_am_not_a_cat
Modified HBR for yamadori collecting?
Replies
15
Views
322
I_I_am_not_a_cat
I_I_am_not_a_cat
minkes
Betula Birch Yamadori next steps
Replies
1
Views
181
MaciekA
MaciekA
minkes
Ulmus minor? yamadori and next steps
Replies
8
Views
253
minkes
minkes
Back
Top Bottom