Will a 6" living log make roots?

Atom#28

Chumono
Messages
557
Reaction score
1,271
Location
Eastern WA
USDA Zone
6b
Super dopey newbie question:

A neighbor uprooted a cool elm tree. Then he hacked the entire rootball off. There was literally only one root remaining.
DAMN! Its a cool trunk.
So I took it home and put what is now basically a log into a box of pumice and sphagnum moss. Is there any chance this thing is viable? Will a log make roots? (Pics will follow when I get home.)
 
There's a chance. It's an elm. They're tough. Get it home bury the bottom of the trunk with bonsai soil--up to and over the first two inches of the trunk itself. Keep the container warm--like in 6 hours of sun. and wait...
 
There's a chance. It's an elm. They're tough. Get it home bury the bottom of the trunk with bonsai soil--up to and over the first two inches of the trunk itself. Keep the container warm--like in 6 hours of sun. and wait...

Thank you! You've given this greenhorn hope.
I draped a dark trash bag over it as well....
 
Thank you! You've given this greenhorn hope.
I draped a dark trash bag over it as well....
Wouldn't get too attached to it though...odds are it's not gonna do much.
 
If indeed it still has 1 root clinging to it, and it has not been laying about for weeks, it should have a good shot.

Do the black bag sweating thing yeah. And keep the roots warm. Yeah.

Hope.
 
It will probably sprout advantageous buds but they will probably all die. Could be wrong but this is what I believe. I remember about 40 some years ago I was doing some work at a farm where several posts had been set using fresh cut trees. There were a few different types of trees. Many of them sprouted new growth and some of these shoots grew 2 to 3 foot. Eventually they all died. None produced roots, they were just using stored energy.
Of course anything is possible and I wish you luck.
I somehow missed where you said one root was remaining. That sure increases your chances.
 
Its in a pot so leave it alone for three years and just feed and water it . Then stick it on a slab .
49605271293_d97f3ff0be_c.jpg
 
Awesome! that perspective makes the tree look 15 feet tall!!!
 
I found this branch already cut off and discarded . I drilled it then stuck a root from who knows what through it . This was over a year ago and its still alive . Probably just stored energy but nature is amazing .
32259886598_b2a393bcd1_c.jpg

I dont even know what tree its from :oops:
 
Makes sense that a black bag would get hotter....but no light......
It is an Elm after all....

i believe the sweating technique is used for recently collected trees, up until they begin pushing new growth. I am no expert but it seems the purpose is to give the trees plenty of moisture and warmth, stability (in moisture and warmth), and preclude any shocks (given the stability). Once the growth has pushed and the leaves are visible (the tips and green-ish portions) then the black bag no longer serves any purpose other than to continue the green-house effect. Those buds need to "see" daylight to begin photosynthesis, which is one reason collection is best done during the very end of dormancy. That is not to say that a clear bag isn't useful, which is why cold frames and greenhouses are useful in cultivation. So, as I understand the technique, once you see growth, either transition them out of the bag or put them into an environment where they will begin to get enough light to sustain their metabolic functions.
 
Unbelievable! '' Getting through a bitter winter''? Your first post was in March, end of winter, so when was cutted and planted back without roots? Could you please recap the whole process?
 
Unbelievable! '' Getting through a bitter winter''? Your first post was in March, end of winter, so when was cutted and planted back without roots? Could you please recap the whole process?

You are correct, I dug this fella in March. I was so dismayed when I found a 5” diameter tap root that went straight under the sidewalk, but I took it home anyways. There was one single tiny feeder root that I decided I needed to spare, hence the bizarre planting angle.
After I cleaned up the base, I wired it into a goofy homemade box, backfilled with pure pumice, sprinkled a bit of diluted rooting hormone solution, and covered the entire thing with a black garbage bag. I left it in a sunny spot for about 3 weeks, and buds began to form. Unfortunately, I couldn’t get any buds to break in the old wood, so I will probably be doing some grafting. I plan to cut the trunk shorter this spring to work on developing a more tapered trunk. Here’s the log in March 2020, with the first emerging buds:D8B17990-5821-4BEC-B046-E7C7C8374B74.jpeg0204463F-57AC-4352-AAC7-FFA8A27F45AE.jpeg


Aftercare consisted of sunlight and water! So my comment about making it through this winter: I have some concern that most of the foliar mass was grown via reserved energy within the log. Ihave not looked to see what, if any, root system has developed, and as a new bonsaiist, I don’t really know if I need to provide special protection going into it’s first winter as a living log. I can definitely vouch for the insane vigor and resilience of this (elm?), so I am somewhat confident it will continue to thrive if it survives winter #1. More pics to follow...
 
Back
Top Bottom