Most common beginner mistakes

Oboedatree

Sapling
Messages
28
Reaction score
36
Location
pittsburgh, PA
USDA Zone
6b
Hey there! I'm wondering what the most common beginner mistakes are, haven't gotten my first tree yet but I plan to this coming spring. I know about the basic mistakes such as over watering as a quick example, but I can't seem to find some more common yet not to "picky" mistakes. Basically I just want a list of a couple more in-depth issues.

Thanks!
 
Strangely, I thought about starting a thread based on the same goal, earlier today.

The reason I didn't is because horticulture is well documented. Bonsai horticulture is also well documented.

What we're all looking for is a standard, but that doesn't really exist. Everyone lives in different environments, uses different soil medium, works with plants trying to survive both.

I just don't think a standard exists to be found. 🙂
 
Over watering.
Under watering.
Both in turn.
Getting bored and forgetting to care for the tree.
Purchasing weak trees and then attempting to work them before recovery.

I’ve made all of these mistakes, and I know people who’ve been doing bonsai a long time who still make them.
 
Keeping an outdoor Tree indoors.
Repotting out of season.
Buying a tree that doesn't work in your environment.
Not researching a tree before you buy.
Not adjusting care to the seasons. (I.E. water more in Summer, less in Winter)
putting these in the notes, thanks!
 
Strangely, I thought about starting a thread based on the same goal, earlier today.

The reason I didn't is because horticulture is well documented. Bonsai horticulture is also well documented.

What we're all looking for is a standard, but that doesn't really exist. Everyone lives in different environments, uses different soil medium, works with plants trying to survive both.

I just don't think a standard exists to be found. 🙂
huh, never thought of it that way. also going in the notes!
 
Picking a Fukien Tea for your first tree. I will most likely end in 😭.
It was my first, given to me. It hasn't ever been outside, but still produces flowers. Had it for about 6 years.

I don't consider it my first, because to me it's a plant like any other. But I don't think they're all that difficult to care for. Junipers, on the other hand, are widely hailed as a good beginner tree, but most people I talk to have had horrible luck with them because they aren't easy.
 
Mine both have to do with a scale and proportion.
I would say not growing out material and starting with something that is insignificant which doesn’t inspire you.
And on the flipside…
Not starting with something larger and reducing it to the size you want. It’s way easier to start with something bigger and cut it back then to grow something out from scratch in most cases.

Another thing I would say is getting too many species at once and not understanding the care of any of them. If I were to start again, I would just start with two or three species and get a few trees of those species to experiment with.
Regardless of what you’ll do, you’ll have fun with that.
Welcome to the addiction.
 
Outside of the commonly listed mistakes, I think one of the biggest mistakes a bigger can make is practicing refinement techniques when the should be performing structural work.

I sort of fell into this mistake myself even when I was trying to avoid it. Just this year, I took a hard look at my trees and realized quite of few of them still needed major structural work to build the correct taper and branch thicknesses.

What I mostly mean by this mistake is leaving "as recieved" branches (nursery stock, collect, etc.) and removing the smaller twigs or adventurous buds. This leaves branches that are either too thick or will be too thick in the near future in accordance with the main trunk. Making for an awkward and young looking tree.

By removing the larger branches, you instead focus on the smaller and newer growth to begin building your branches for ramification/division close to the trunk and the thickness years down the line will look more appropriate.

Another aspect of this mistake is working on secondary/tertiary division when the branch is way too long and/or thick for the eventual composition.

The easiest summery of the mistake is essentially, pruning and working in the tree with a short-term outlook (as in thinking and planning for the next year or two) instead of working of a tree with a long-term mindset. Making a tree "good-ish" now instead of amazing years down the road.

I linked some videos that show case some of the ideas I mentioned as well as @leatherback talking about this sort of error. If he jumps in here, he can probably speak more on the points he talked about.

Part One of Eric's video on a beginner mistake

Part Two showing a follow up on what the trees looked like later on.

Leatherback's Video coming across this mistake
 
Trying to use intermediate or advanced techniques before simply learning what the tree needs to survive/thrive.

Assuming that traditional horticulture is all that is needed to know for bonsai. It's a fair starting point, but you'll be sorely disappointed with the results if you don't use some of the tried and true techniques of bonsai culture.
 
Not understanding the stage their material is at? Putting the material in a bonsai pot before it is ready for that step Selecting poor quality material to begin with.
Sadly, number two on your list “Putting the material in a bonsai pot before it is ready for that step” is something seen not just in beginners, but also in intermediate folks.

My favorite has already been taken…. ‘Doing just about anything to a tree, then making a thread asking did I do this right afterwards?’

However, adding to this beginner/intermediate list

1. Repotting a nursery azalea into kanuma without completely washing the roots clean of the nursery media.
2. Slip potting a tree into a pot and adding a dissimilar media.
3. Buying a tree you have never worked with and thinking it’s treated like all the others you’ve worked on.
4. Potting an azalea in a “cute”, yet way too shallow or small pot. (Substitute Chojubai etc for azalea as well.)

Cheers
DSD sends
 
Back
Top Bottom