8 year old lemon tree is struggling

Thank you, everyone, for the feedback and suggestions.

Is there hope for keeping the plant alive if I buy a grow light? I haven't looked into grow lights too much but if anyone could provide suggestions on if that's a good idea and if so, which grow lights to consider that would be much appreciated.

First, welcome to Bonsai Nut. And to a life long hobby. Do edit your profile to include your location for future posts.

Okay - I will work within the restrictions you outlined. Indoors, period. That is okay.

Looking at the view from your window, you have a large window there, with no obstructions. That window is brighter than most windows, because of its large size. You might do okay, or good enough with this window, without adding grow lights.

The moisture meter has me concerned, my concern is for accuracy. The most accurate moisture meter ever invented is the human finger. Just dig your finger in to at least bury your finger nail into the media. If it feels wet, don't water, cool and moist, - still don't water. When it feels just barely damp, it is time to water. If it feels bone dry, you should have watered yesterday. Each time you stick your finger into the mix, check your meter. See what the meter says. If the meter agrees across the range from wet to dry, then you can trust the meter. If the meter and your finger disagree - trust your finger, not the meter. Without spending thousands of dollars, moisture meters are notorious for being wildly inaccurate. Don't waste time on gadgets.

Each time you check the moisture with your finger, also pick up the pot. Note the weight of the pot. In very little time you will "calibrate" your sense of weight, a dry pot will be light, a wet pot will be heavy. Soon just picking up the edge of the pot, you will know just how wet or dry it is by weight alone.

Now - when you water, pick up the tree and walk it over to a sink, or even the slop sink in the janitor's closet, water by flooding the surface of the soil with water. Flood, then let drain in the sink, then flood again, let drain again. This repeat flooding makes sure there are no dry pockets of media in the pot. It also lets you observe your drainage. Once the tree has drained enough to not be dripping, Return it to the windowsill to grow. Just dribbling a little water into the pot while it is on the windowsill is a recipe for disaster, because bonsai media in particular, but many soils do not wick water around. so one side of the pot will be dry, the other might be wet. This is an unhealthy way to water. So always, pick up the tree, walk it to the sink, flood it with water, at least 2 or 3 times. Let drain. Return to the windowsill. Proper watering is key to success indoors.

If you can not bring the tree to a sink, bring a 3 gallon bucket of water to the tree. Dunk the pot into the water. Hold it while it drains, dunk again. Let drain. Return to the window. You can put a dilute dose of fertilizer into the bucket of water, and get your fertilizing done at the same time.

The single most important gadget you can buy is a fan. Yep, just a cheap 4 inch, to 9 inch fan, for less than $20, maybe less than $10 on sale. Set the fan either on the windowsill to one side or the other, and have it blow continuously 24/7 at your little tree. You can turn it so it just barely makes the leaves wave, but the leaves fluttering would be no problem. I have multiple fans in my grow areas, no matter where you look in the light garden, the leaves are waving at least gently. This will keep the air moving over the soil, getting air to move into your soil, the air across the leaves will cut down on insects like spider mites. The list of benefits are huge, just get a little fan, even a little one meant for cooling a laptop will work.

Last, those white dots on the undersides of your leaves. Take a good look, I think they are one of the many mite species (8 legs) or possibly leaf miners (6 legs). You need an insecticide, not a fungicide. There are many from the big box stores that will work. make sure you read the label. It must list that it is for indoor houseplants, and the label must say it is effective against mites and insects like thrips and leaf miners. The pesticide will be more effective if you turn the fan off. Spray, then turn the fan back on.

Notice, I haven't said anything about "doing bonsai", all of this is horticulture. Let's just keep this lemon growing for a year, before worrying about turning it into bonsai. If all goes well, you will have more branches to choose from when it does come time to turn this into bonsai.
 
moisture meter

Polka Dotted Rhino!

Finally.

Thanks Leo.

I can't believe we got to page 2 without KNOWING it's a watering problem.

I found 5 bottles of superthrive at Walmart yesterday. They are still there.
Right next to the fucking Moisture Meters!

Sorce
 
s there hope for keeping the plant alive if I buy a grow light?
Why not buy a plant that will thrive in the environment that you have? Ficus/Tea tree. I have a tea tree in southern facing window with a shade screen on it that is doing well.
 
First, welcome to Bonsai Nut. And to a life long hobby. Do edit your profile to include your location for future posts.

Okay - I will work within the restrictions you outlined. Indoors, period. That is okay.

Looking at the view from your window, you have a large window there, with no obstructions. That window is brighter than most windows, because of its large size. You might do okay, or good enough with this window, without adding grow lights.

The moisture meter has me concerned, my concern is for accuracy. The most accurate moisture meter ever invented is the human finger. Just dig your finger in to at least bury your finger nail into the media. If it feels wet, don't water, cool and moist, - still don't water. When it feels just barely damp, it is time to water. If it feels bone dry, you should have watered yesterday. Each time you stick your finger into the mix, check your meter. See what the meter says. If the meter agrees across the range from wet to dry, then you can trust the meter. If the meter and your finger disagree - trust your finger, not the meter. Without spending thousands of dollars, moisture meters are notorious for being wildly inaccurate. Don't waste time on gadgets.

Each time you check the moisture with your finger, also pick up the pot. Note the weight of the pot. In very little time you will "calibrate" your sense of weight, a dry pot will be light, a wet pot will be heavy. Soon just picking up the edge of the pot, you will know just how wet or dry it is by weight alone.

Now - when you water, pick up the tree and walk it over to a sink, or even the slop sink in the janitor's closet, water by flooding the surface of the soil with water. Flood, then let drain in the sink, then flood again, let drain again. This repeat flooding makes sure there are no dry pockets of media in the pot. It also lets you observe your drainage. Once the tree has drained enough to not be dripping, Return it to the windowsill to grow. Just dribbling a little water into the pot while it is on the windowsill is a recipe for disaster, because bonsai media in particular, but many soils do not wick water around. so one side of the pot will be dry, the other might be wet. This is an unhealthy way to water. So always, pick up the tree, walk it to the sink, flood it with water, at least 2 or 3 times. Let drain. Return to the windowsill. Proper watering is key to success indoors.

If you can not bring the tree to a sink, bring a 3 gallon bucket of water to the tree. Dunk the pot into the water. Hold it while it drains, dunk again. Let drain. Return to the window. You can put a dilute dose of fertilizer into the bucket of water, and get your fertilizing done at the same time.

The single most important gadget you can buy is a fan. Yep, just a cheap 4 inch, to 9 inch fan, for less than $20, maybe less than $10 on sale. Set the fan either on the windowsill to one side or the other, and have it blow continuously 24/7 at your little tree. You can turn it so it just barely makes the leaves wave, but the leaves fluttering would be no problem. I have multiple fans in my grow areas, no matter where you look in the light garden, the leaves are waving at least gently. This will keep the air moving over the soil, getting air to move into your soil, the air across the leaves will cut down on insects like spider mites. The list of benefits are huge, just get a little fan, even a little one meant for cooling a laptop will work.

Last, those white dots on the undersides of your leaves. Take a good look, I think they are one of the many mite species (8 legs) or possibly leaf miners (6 legs). You need an insecticide, not a fungicide. There are many from the big box stores that will work. make sure you read the label. It must list that it is for indoor houseplants, and the label must say it is effective against mites and insects like thrips and leaf miners. The pesticide will be more effective if you turn the fan off. Spray, then turn the fan back on.

Notice, I haven't said anything about "doing bonsai", all of this is horticulture. Let's just keep this lemon growing for a year, before worrying about turning it into bonsai. If all goes well, you will have more branches to choose from when it does come time to turn this into bonsai.

Thank you for all of the information and guidance, this is much appreciated.

I've established that the moisture meter is pointless after using my finger to gauge when the tree needs water and started watering it using the method you noted. I'm almost positive that I was watering the tree far too much when I did water it.

I bought an insecticide and treated the tree with that, and have a small fan that should arrive tomorrow.

In other news, for better or for worse someone (I'm assuming the cleaning people at my work) picked off all of the yellow leaves. Since this, I haven't had additional leaves turn yellow and fall off.

Here are some images of the current status, the buds have grown a good bit over the last week or so. Hopefully, I'll have some flowers sooner than later :)

IMG_20191018_073124.jpg

IMG_20191018_073137.jpg

IMG_20191018_073213.jpg

IMG_20191018_073152.jpg

Thanks to all for the suggestions and feedback. As of now, I need to buy is a larger clay tray for the pot to sit in, so when I leave it at work for the weekend it can hold enough water to last the whole weekend.

I need to do some further research as I'm not sure what the white spots are that you can see in the last close up images, they almost look like water spots from spraying the foilage but I haven't done that since starting this thread.
 
Back
Top Bottom