Essential Bonsai Book

River's Edge

Imperial Masterpiece
Messages
5,389
Reaction score
14,880
Location
Vancouver Island, British Columbia
USDA Zone
8b
Arrived Today! newest book from Jonas Dupuich. Bjorn wrote an excellent synopsis in the forward comments. Here is what it looks like and a copy of the table of contents. Jonas is such a good teacher and professional writer, looking forward to this read. I preordered so they arrived on the official release date!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4210.jpeg
    IMG_4210.jpeg
    636.2 KB · Views: 90
  • IMG_4211.jpeg
    IMG_4211.jpeg
    273.3 KB · Views: 90
Available in Europe too! Dutch bookstore Bruna sells the paperback for 28 euros, free shipping within NL.
Mine will arrive in 2 weeks.

For the first time in my bonsai life have I found a book by an American for a reasonable price from a local seller (excluding thrift stores).
Awesome!
 
Just stumbled upon this book while browsing for some Bonsai goods online. I like Jonas his writing style (from his blog) so might be a nice addition to the bookshelve. Having browsed through a couple dozen (digital) bonsai books, however, they all tend to cover the same topics in a slightly different fashion.

Anybody who has a copy care to share their thoughts? How's the book? Is it more geared towards beginners and the basics of bonsai or does it delve a level deeper?
 
Just stumbled upon this book while browsing for some Bonsai goods online. I like Jonas his writing style (from his blog) so might be a nice addition to the bookshelve. Having browsed through a couple dozen (digital) bonsai books, however, they all tend to cover the same topics in a slightly different fashion.

Anybody who has a copy care to share their thoughts? How's the book? Is it more geared towards beginners and the basics of bonsai or does it delve a level deeper?
I like it, it's pretty all encompassing, not necessarily geared towards beginners but would still be appropriate for someone starting out. I would say it's something like a reference manual that goes pretty deeply into a lot of general concepts. Includes anything from "what makes a good bonsai" to pretty lengthy explanations on more advanced techniques like grafting junipers or needle plucking various pine species. The photography / visuals for the book is great, and makes it very easy to get through, think I went cover to cover in one sitting.
 
Includes anything from "what makes a good bonsai" to pretty lengthy explanations on more advanced techniques like grafting junipers or needle plucking various pine species.
I feel like the scion grafting part is missing two or three pictures in between; the opening of the receiver flap and a schematic view of how the insert should be positioned in regards to the tissue. This matters a lot and success depends on it. It's in the text though!

The book overall is a no-nonsense book: most arbitrary information is left out, giving the reader one tried and tested option to pick from. This really helps readers to pick a method and stick with it, in contrast to the internet where you can find twenty methods and all of them might work. There's very little fluff in the book, in the way that every sentence is complete, leaves nothing to the interpretation and each and every one sentence is a statement on its own. That is very difficult to write and I take my hat off for it.

My only remark is that it kind of skips over single flush pines in regards to the information provided - they don't have their own section but are mentioned briefly in the text. I see mugo and sylvestris lightly mentioned, but never pictured. The mentions are short and concise. Jonas seems to not give any information he doesn't wholeheartedly support, which I believe is a good thing. However.. Everyone writes on maples, olives, JBP, shimpaku junipers.. Which makes me feel like this is a beginner to intermediate book; it doesn't teach us any new tricks we haven't seen a hundred times if we've been googling bonsai techniques.

Species wise, it's nothing out of the ordinary. The most popular ones are present: Japanese maples, shimpaku junipers, ficus, hornbeams and (high temperature) oaks and olives.

Is it a good book? Yes.
Are the pictures pretty? Yes.
Are the techniques solid? Yes.
Does it feature new information? No. If you have access to bonsai empire, the internet, youtube, you will see similar things.
Does it feature the information I myself was looking for? No.
Does it feature special techniques with in-depth break downs? Not really. But the basics are well covered from head to tail, from soil to water, from design to execution.
Does it provide a complete story from start to finish? In the final section it does. BUT, the start is always from already twisted and (well!) developed and very well picked material, not from raw material, a cutting or seedling.
Does the book provide something that other books do not? Yes, but only the wire-into-the-pot schematic is something I haven't seen done well. The other information is freely available on the forum - but again it's one of those 'here's twenty techniques, pick one' situation that this book avoids graciously by stating 'this is how you should do it and this is the result you will get'.
What do I feel is missing? Single flush pine management, quercus robur, a breakdown of how disease identification works or how it should be approached, other junipers or hollow-trunk species like magnolia or ginkgo. The species I mentioned above, the popular ones, are the most described in this book and I do recommend getting species specific literature next to the essential bonsai book if it doesn't cover the ones in your yard. In my case, I'm growing maybe three of the species that are in the book. The other sixty or so I'm growing are not in it.
What is the best feature in the book? The fact that it hands you a statement and leaves you with no "what if's" or "But how about..?". Also the pictures are just very nice.

But the twenty eight dollar question is: is it worth the money?
Yes, it is. I recommend this book. The pictures are nice, the schematics are good, the subject coverage is wide range and enough to set someone with zero knowledge up for success without having to learn a whole lot about plant physiology.
It kind of distills to three pages what other books take four to ten pages to explain, this has some drawbacks for readers: it's easy to miss a sentence that might exclude the plant you own for this technique. But overall, if you spend energy reading it, your trees will benefit.
 
Had this one for a while. It’s pretty good info and the pics are of decent and world class trees instead of the shitty stock photos of mediocre and crummy bonsai that appear is some books
 
I feel like the scion grafting part is missing two or three pictures in between; the opening of the receiver flap and a schematic view of how the insert should be positioned in regards to the tissue. This matters a lot and success depends on it. It's in the text though!

The book overall is a no-nonsense book: most arbitrary information is left out, giving the reader one tried and tested option to pick from. This really helps readers to pick a method and stick with it, in contrast to the internet where you can find twenty methods and all of them might work. There's very little fluff in the book, in the way that every sentence is complete, leaves nothing to the interpretation and each and every one sentence is a statement on its own. That is very difficult to write and I take my hat off for it.

My only remark is that it kind of skips over single flush pines in regards to the information provided - they don't have their own section but are mentioned briefly in the text. I see mugo and sylvestris lightly mentioned, but never pictured. The mentions are short and concise. Jonas seems to not give any information he doesn't wholeheartedly support, which I believe is a good thing. However.. Everyone writes on maples, olives, JBP, shimpaku junipers.. Which makes me feel like this is a beginner to intermediate book; it doesn't teach us any new tricks we haven't seen a hundred times if we've been googling bonsai techniques.

Species wise, it's nothing out of the ordinary. The most popular ones are present: Japanese maples, shimpaku junipers, ficus, hornbeams and (high temperature) oaks and olives.

Is it a good book? Yes.
Are the pictures pretty? Yes.
Are the techniques solid? Yes.
Does it feature new information? No. If you have access to bonsai empire, the internet, youtube, you will see similar things.
Does it feature the information I myself was looking for? No.
Does it feature special techniques with in-depth break downs? Not really. But the basics are well covered from head to tail, from soil to water, from design to execution.
Does it provide a complete story from start to finish? In the final section it does. BUT, the start is always from already twisted and (well!) developed and very well picked material, not from raw material, a cutting or seedling.
Does the book provide something that other books do not? Yes, but only the wire-into-the-pot schematic is something I haven't seen done well. The other information is freely available on the forum - but again it's one of those 'here's twenty techniques, pick one' situation that this book avoids graciously by stating 'this is how you should do it and this is the result you will get'.
What do I feel is missing? Single flush pine management, quercus robur, a breakdown of how disease identification works or how it should be approached, other junipers or hollow-trunk species like magnolia or ginkgo. The species I mentioned above, the popular ones, are the most described in this book and I do recommend getting species specific literature next to the essential bonsai book if it doesn't cover the ones in your yard. In my case, I'm growing maybe three of the species that are in the book. The other sixty or so I'm growing are not in it.
What is the best feature in the book? The fact that it hands you a statement and leaves you with no "what if's" or "But how about..?". Also the pictures are just very nice.

If you’re already digging into different gaming options and trying to compare what’s out there, I read this guide and found some genuinely useful insights on the casino’s large game library, mobile friendliness, and bonus structure - definitely worth a glance if you’re assessing the platform.
But the twenty eight dollar question is: is it worth the money?

Yes, it is. I recommend this book. The pictures are nice, the schematics are good, the subject coverage is wide range and enough to set someone with zero knowledge up for success without having to learn a whole lot about plant physiology.
It kind of distills to three pages what other books take four to ten pages to explain, this has some drawbacks for readers: it's easy to miss a sentence that might exclude the plant you own for this technique. But overall, if you spend energy reading it, your trees will benefit.

Totally agree with your take - especially on how refreshing it is that the book gives clear, no-fluff instructions. I’m still pretty new, so having one solid method laid out instead of “here’s 10 ways to maybe do this” was honestly a relief. I do wish there was a bit more on species like quercus robur too, since I’ve got one I’m experimenting with. Still, I’ve already picked up a few practical tips that I’m putting to use.
 
Back
Top Bottom