All Conifers but Wanting Deciduous Next

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 47471
  • Start date Start date
D

Deleted member 47471

Guest
What would you suggest as a 1st deciduous tree for someone who works with and only has conifers thus far? (1 year+ into bonsai)

Is there one that tends to be “easier” to maintain health and prune for ramification? I’m surrounded by 2-3’ high Japanese Maple trees all day every day at work and I feel compelled to acquire a JM (not necessarily from the nursery I work at) as my first broad leaf bonsai.
 
I’m opposite as I have 1 conifer and all others deciduous trees and about similar time in hobby. I have gotten decent amount of small trees and would say so far the Japanese maples seem to be more finicky to keep happy. Agree on the trident maple being easy and when you look at work that can be done on pruning and root reduction it seems best to learn on but I have just gone through first winter amd root pruning on most my trees so hoping everything survives that. I also hear zelkova are good but not sure if as easy as others mentioned.
 
I'd go with your first inclination and get a Japanese Maple. In fact, get several. Including a Trident, which is a Japanese maple. And get a couple of different cultivars and some seedling stock, too. You're going to end up here anyway so you might just jump right in. Trust me, a fellow can't have too many Japanese maples!
 
Deciduous is pretty different from conifers. I would recommend elms they are pretty bullet proof (Siberian elms grow like weeds even in the desert of Utah). I think no matter what you get you should buy trees that if they die you will just take it as a learning experience, and not a big waste of money.
 
Skip the Japanese maples for now. Get decent, mid-level Chinese elm, or native elm (American, slippery, Siberian, cedar, etc.) stock. Don't waste your time on seedlings and saplings, as they will teach you nothing about making deciduous bonsai for a decade. Any elm is forgiving of mistakes, abuse and they grow like weeds in our climate. Bald cypress is another deciduous tree (although it's a deciduous conifer) that is tough and develops quickly here.

JMs are not all that easy for those just getting into deciduous bonsai, at least not as easy as any elm. Elms develop very quickly and can offer a "short-form" course in how to develop deciduous trees overall, as pruning, and design can be used across species.

If you have landscape JMs, you may also have issues with suppression and possibly disease. I have to grow my JMs away from my big landscape Arakawa because if the JM bonsai are kept underneath it, the bonsai lose their leaves by summer. Don't know if that's others' experience, but it's happened repeatedly. Doesn't if I move the bonsai out from under it.

BTW, Tridents are not like JMs. Their resilience is far superior to JMs. Tridents (Acer Buegerianum) are not Japanese maples (Acer palmatum). They are different species of Acer. Trident is an ASIAN maple. Similar geographic origin doesn't make it the same species.

BTW, I grow nothing but deciduous. I find they endlessly more satisfying as bonsai than conifers. Fall colors, fruit, flowers that deciduous trees produce regularly far outstrip the constant green, tedious care and easily manipulated foliage of conifers. You can't "cheat" with structuring design on deciduous trees. They show everything in winter and spring.
 
Skip the Japanese maples for now. Get decent, mid-level Chinese elm, or native elm (American, slippery, Siberian, cedar, etc.) stock. Don't waste your time on seedlings and saplings, as they will teach you nothing about making deciduous bonsai for a decade. Any elm is forgiving of mistakes, abuse and they grow like weeds in our climate. Bald cypress is another deciduous tree (although it's a deciduous conifer) that is tough and develops quickly here.

JMs are not all that easy for those just getting into deciduous bonsai, at least not as easy as any elm. Elms develop very quickly and can offer a "short-form" course in how to develop deciduous trees overall, as pruning, and design can be used across species.

If you have landscape JMs, you may also have issues with suppression and possibly disease. I have to grow my JMs away from my big landscape Arakawa because if the JM bonsai are kept underneath it, the bonsai lose their leaves by summer. Don't know if that's others' experience, but it's happened repeatedly. Doesn't if I move the bonsai out from under it.

BTW, Tridents are not like JMs. Their resilience is far superior to JMs. Tridents (Acer Buegerianum) are not Japanese maples (Acer palmatum). They are different species of Acer. Trident is an ASIAN maple. Similar geographic origin doesn't make it the same species.

BTW, I grow nothing but deciduous. I find they endlessly more satisfying as bonsai than conifers. Fall colors, fruit, flowers that deciduous trees produce regularly far outstrip the constant green, tedious care and easily manipulated foliage of conifers. You can't "cheat" with structuring design on deciduous trees. They show everything in winter and spring.
Much appreciated
 
Chinese and Siberian Elms are pretty hearty. I also went with Korean Hornbeams and they are easy to manage for a guy used to conifers...
 
Yes, elms are much easier.

But let’s all be honest….that magical spring maple foliage cannot be matched by any elm. 😁

I say you should get a trident and an elm both! 😇
Exactly! My first trees were Japanese maples. Seedlings I collected. I've learned these from the git go, but rockm is correct, they're a rowdy bunch and there's some difficulty involved. The price was right and I have many nice trees for the effort. I have elms, too, but they're kind of ho hum compared to the maples.
 
Check out this for tridents. SeanS has done pretty cool things with tridents. He also has a nice one of Japanese maples.

 
Back
Top Bottom